Nelson Bustamante: Risks in Public-Private Partnership (PPP) Projects

🕑 Reading time: 1 minute

In the realm of Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs), where governments and private entities collaborate to tackle infrastructure projects, risks abound. It is imperative for both public and private stakeholders to not only comprehend these risks but also devise strategies to mitigate them effectively. The allure of PPPs lies in the promise of rewards, but these rewards must outweigh the inherent risks for promoters to take the plunge.

The Risk Spectrum in PPP Projects

Public-Private Partnership (PPP) projects encompass a vast spectrum of risks, each demanding vigilant consideration and proactive management. Let’s delve into these risk categories to gain a deeper understanding of the challenges that underpin these collaborative endeavors:

Risks in PPP Projects
Risks Involved in Public Private Partnerships

1. Construction Risks:

Construction risks constitute a substantial facet of PPP projects, and they stem from various factors that influence infrastructure development. Key risk factors in this domain include:

Estimated Cost vs. Real Project Cost: In a majority of cases, the actual project cost exceeds the initial estimates. This discrepancy can be attributed to a multitude of factors, including inefficient working practices, delays in obtaining public sector approvals, design modifications, and the imposition of new taxes. Private entities, often contractors, find themselves entangled in these cost overruns.

Project Completion Time: Meeting project timelines falls under the purview of private parties, particularly contractors. Their responsibility is to ensure timely project completion, an obligation fraught with its own set of risks.

Standards of Construction: The maintenance of high construction standards is pivotal in risk mitigation. Routine inspections by the public sector can help uphold these standards and reduce the likelihood of construction-related issues.

Construction Risk
Fig 2: Time Vs Cost

2. Operating Risks:

Operating risks revolve around the operation and maintenance costs associated with project infrastructure. Generally, private entities bear the brunt of these risks, but they can be exacerbated by new or increased taxes. Enhancing the sustainability of long-term PPP projects necessitates periodic reviews and adjustments to charges.

3. Design Risks:

Design risks hinge on mistakes or defects in the design specifications or structural elements. Distinguishing whether damage to structural elements results from design parameter errors or inherent design flaws can be challenging. However, these risks predominantly fall under the purview of design contractors, underscoring the importance of their role in eliminating such vulnerabilities during the design phase.

4. Market and Revenue Risks:

Revenue risks surface when a project fails to generate anticipated income. PPP projects can grapple with market and revenue risks due to several factors:

Insufficient Income from Fares or Tolls: Revenue risk materializes when fares or toll collections fall short of expectations. In such instances, private sectors may seek cash compensation from the public sector, request fare or toll increases, or propose extensions to the concession period.

Insufficient Income from Other Operations: If revenue risk stems from inadequate income generated through other operations, private entities can petition the government to prolong the concession period to offset these financial shortfalls.

Insufficient Traffic: Government support for PPP projects hinges on achieving satisfactory traffic levels. Unsatisfactory traffic can result in a lack of compensations from the government, thus amplifying revenue risks.

Legal risks within public-private partnership projects can manifest due to various reasons, including:

Property Lease Issues: Disputes surrounding property leases or ownership disputes can expose projects to legal vulnerabilities.

Ownership Assents: Issues related to ownership rights and claims can pose legal risks that demand careful consideration.

Breach of Documents: Contractual breaches, financial failures, and security-related concerns introduce legal complexities that necessitate thorough attention.

Financial Failure of Private Sector: The financial instability of private entities involved in PPP projects can trigger legal ramifications that impact project continuity.

Corporate and Security Structure: Complexities in corporate and security structures can add a layer of legal intricacy to these partnerships.

6. Financial Risks:

The financial dimension of PPP projects, often requiring substantial working capital, gives rise to financial risks. These risks manifest in two primary ways, necessitating serious deliberation by both parties involved:

Exchange Rate Risk: In projects involving foreign currency exchange or international finance, fluctuations in exchange rates can introduce financial instability. Given the volatility of international currency exchange rates, this risk warrants meticulous consideration.

Interest Rate Risk: Borrowing significant sums of money for projects at variable interest rates exposes them to interest rate risks. To mitigate these risks, borrowing funds at fixed interest rates and aligning loan periods with project duration are essential strategies.

Revenue Risk
Fig : Revenue Risk

7. Political Risks:

Political risks are an inherent facet of PPP projects, stemming from interactions with various public sector entities, including the incumbent government, opposition parties, and legislative bodies. These risks encompass:

Nationalization of Project: The government may choose to nationalize a project, essentially taking it over, which can disrupt the intended collaboration.

Tax Increment: Changes in tax policies, such as tax increments, can adversely impact project finances and profitability.

Payment Failure by Public Sector: Delays or failures in payments by the public sector can strain the financial viability of PPP projects.

Delay in Approvals from Public Authority: Lengthy delays in obtaining approvals from public authorities can lead to project delays, mounting costs, and contractual complexities.

Termination of Private Sector by Public Sector: In some instances, the public sector may terminate the involvement of private entities, leading to project discontinuation.

8. Force Majeure Risks:

Force majeure risks are external events unrelated to project execution that can disrupt PPP projects. These events are beyond the control of either party and can include:

Natural Force Majeure Events: Natural disasters such as floods, earthquakes, and cyclones fall into this category. While they cannot be prevented, proactive safety measures can mitigate their impact, albeit potentially at an increased project cost shared by both parties.

Direct Political Force Majeure Events: Events like exploration activities and nationalization efforts can directly affect PPP projects.

Indirect Political Force Majeure Events: Indirect political events occur in environments characterized by political instability, including wars, riots, and other disturbances, which introduce a layer of unpredictability to projects.

9. Environment Risks:

Environmental risks are tied to the project’s environmental impact during implementation. These risks necessitate a thorough understanding of the regulatory landscape and strict adherence to environmental laws. It is imperative to:

Check for Strict Environmental Liability: Assess the presence of stringent environmental liability within the project area and devise plans to comply with current environmental legislation.

Submit Reports and Obtain Permissions: Initiate the submission of reports and secure permissions from environmental authorities before commencing a project to avert penalties and unforeseen charges.

In conclusion, Public-Private Partnerships represent a unique avenue for driving infrastructure development. However, the road to success is riddled with multifaceted risks that demand meticulous attention and proactive management. To truly harness the potential of PPPs, stakeholders must embrace a holistic approach to risk mitigation, ensuring that the rewards far outweigh the challenges.

Read alsoPublic Private Partnership (PPP) Construction Projects – Types and Benefits

Ver fuente